If Scotland's devolution was to either evolve into maxi-devolution or metamorphose into independence, Scotland's relationship not just with the UK but also the separate regions would be an important consideration.  Any constitutional change in Scotland will have knock on effects in other parts of the UK.  Few would deny that Scotland's relationship with England is important, not just from a historical point of view but also in relation to economic considerations.  A large proportion of Scotland's tourist income comes from south of the border as well as many of the accounts held in Scottish banks.

It has been suggested that momentum for Scottish Independence could originate in England should political parties decided to harness what has been described as "latent discontent".  Voters south of the border have become increasingly frustrated with a lack of answers or debate on the West Lothian question and perceived inequalities between the way Scotland and England are treated, a situation which started to germinate long before the devolution settlement with the introduction of the Barnett Formula, which was originally intended as a short-term measure.  For more on the Barnett Formula please see previous Parliamentary E-bulletins.

Most surveys have found that English preferences for constitutional change almost exactly match the Scottish preferences although, partly due to under reporting in the media, devolution is not viewed in the same way on each side of the border.

Mairi Sharratt
mairi.sharratt@shepwedd.co.uk

18 September 2007

« Back to Article index